Minister in CEC-EC selection panel fails ‘perception test’, says Justice Datta in split verdict
Published · Updated
AI-generated summary of the coverage listed below: The Supreme Court, in a split decision, ruled that a Union Cabinet Minister’s inclusion in the three‑member panel that selects the Chief Election Commissioner and Election Commissioners does not meet the required “perception test” for independence. Justice S. K. Datta explained that the minister cannot be expected to defy the Prime Minister, and that the panel’s composition undermines an independent countenance. The ruling highlights concerns over the integrity of the electoral appointment process. QUOTE: "cannot be expected to defy the Prime Minister" — Justice Datta
Covered by 2 outlets across the spectrum: 50% left, 50% center, 0% right.
Who is covering this story
- Left-leaning (1): The Hindu
- Center (1): Tribune India
Sources
- Minister in CEC-EC selection panel fails ‘perception test’, says Justice Datta in split verdict — The Hindu (left-leaning)
- SC refers pleas on law to appoint CEC, ECs to Constitution Bench — Tribune India (center)